Hong Kong faces 'selection not election' of China's favoured candidate

On Sunday, 1,194 people will choose a new chief executive on behalf of Hong Kong’s nearly 4 million voters but Beijing’s anointed one is far from popular.



Every newly elected leader of Hong Kong takes the oath of office in front of China’s president, below a giant red national flag of China, and the slightly smaller banner of the city.


It is a tightly scripted event designed to shield Chinese officials from the embarrassment of dissenting voices.


In Hong Kong politics, formality is everything, and many say the election for the city’s next leader which happens on Sunday will indeed be a formality.


Most expect Beijing’s preferred candidate to be anointed despite her rival being by far the more popular choice.


The race for the top job, officially known as the chief executive, is largely between two retired civil servants. Carrie Lam was the deputy to the present chief executive, Leung Chun-ying, and is supported by the Chinese government. John Tsang, a former financial secretary, consistently polls ahead of her by a wide margin.


A third candidate is also running, retired judge Woo Kwok-hing, who is neither popular nor politically connected in Beijing.


However, only 1,194 people are able to cast a ballot, far less than the city’s 3.8 million registered voters. Those who have a say include all 70 members of the city’s legislature and some district politicians, business groups, professional unions, pop stars, priests and professors.


“This is entirely controlled by the Beijing government, it’s a selection, not an election,” says Nathan Law, a pro-democracy legislator swept into office in the wake of 2014 street protests agitating for more open elections.


“If Carrie Lam wins, it will be hard for her to govern Hong Kong because she doesn’t have the support from ordinary people.”


The idea that Sunday’s vote is indeed “a selection, not an election” is a mantra repeated across the political spectrum, with many dismayed that citizens in the former British colony have no say in who runs the city.


The Basic Law, Hong Kong’s mini constitution, explicitly states: “The ultimate aim is the selection of the chief executive by universal suffrage”. A political change package pushed by Beijing in 2014 would have allowed a “one person, one vote” system, but candidates would first need to be approved by a committee.


That pre-screening was criticised by pro-democracy activists, eventually erupting into 79 days of street protests that consumed the city.


“I don’t see much of a difference, comparing Lam to CY Leung,” said Law, one of the leaders of those protests. “She’s also responsible for the failure of political reform and the impression she has given during the campaign is that she will be a hardliner.”


Law, who as a legislator is able to vote, plans to submit a blank ballot in protest against Beijing’s outsized influence in the decision and the “small circle” nature of the election.


In the weeks leading up to the vote, the city hardly feels gripped by a battle for hearts and minds. There are no mass political rallies, with much of the electioneering done in closed-door meetings with special interest groups and only a sprinkling of subdued political advertisements around the city.


​Read more from the source article published by The Guardian on Mar. 23 2017.




Please reload

Recent Posts

Please reload


Please reload

To change the world,

first know the world.

Sign up for advance notice of our events.

The World Affairs Council of Western Michigan empowers the people and organizations of West Michigan to engage thoughtfully with the world.

"To change the world, first know the world."

Credible. Objective. Relevant. Civil. Compelling.

1700 Fulton St. SE

Grand Rapids, MI 49506

(616) 776-1721

  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • YouTube Social  Icon
  • LinkedIn Social Icon
World Affairs Councls of America logo

Dedicated to educating and engaging Americans on global issues with nearly 100 councils across 40 states reaching more than half a million people a year.

©2016 – 2018 by the World Affairs Council of Western Michigan. Created by The Vincent Group